Tagamlitzki’s circle
For several decades Tagamlitzki’s circle was at the centre of the development of modern mathematics in our country. It was the school in which generations of Bulgaria’s best mathematicians gained experience and confidence.
Officially the circle was called the “circle in differential and integral calculus”, although in fact it was in functional analysis. The specialised course in functional analysis was distinct from the research circle and was also given while the circle existed (the two complemented each other). Later, after the Unified Centre for Mathematics and Mechanics was set up, the circle became the seminar in real and functional analysis at the sector of the same name. Below we offer some testimonies of participants in this circle* and lectures on functional analysis** given by Tagamlitzki at the end of the 1970s.
Contents
Acad. Blagovest Sendov (student)
Prof. Doychin Doychinov (assistant)
Prof. Dimiter Skordev (student)
Prof. Vl. Chakalov, Prof. D. Skordev (students)
Lectures by Prof. Tagamlitzki from the circle in functional analysis (1977–1978)
Acad. Ivan Todorov (student)
We did not realise how modest the name was: a circle (instead of the more pretentious “seminar”) in differential and integral calculus – after the name of the subject taught to first- and second-year students (not in functional analysis – the modern branch of mathematics into which our teacher was introducing us). In the early fifties our faculty was not spoiled by an abundance of special courses and seminars, and Prof. Tagamlitzki’s circle, like his lectures on functional analysis (which were different every year), was a centre of attraction for inquisitive students and young assistants. The core of the circle when we joined it consisted of the senior students (one year ahead of us) Dimiter Dobrev (its chairman), Kolyo Stoev (both passed away before their time), Todor Genchev and Stancho Dimiev; among the mathematicians of our year Vladimir Alexandrov stood out; in the year after us shone Blagovest Sendov, who graduated together with us, taking the examinations of two years in one; and the youngest of us – Tagamlitzki’s favourite – Dimiter Skordev joined the work of the circle early. The first serious problem set before the participants in the circle (which, in hindsight, I realise was still of an instructional nature) was Bochner’s theorem on the integral representation of positive definite functions. It proved to be within the powers only of the circle members who were assistants and doctoral students (Doychin Doychinov, Apostol Obretenov, Boyan Penkov). The main direction of the circle’s work was the application of geometric ideas (Minkowski’s separation theorem, the theorem on cones) to “spaces” of functions.
Acad. Blagovest Sendov (student)
As a second-year student I was greatly concerned whether Prof. Tagamlitzki would invite me as a listener to his circle. In that circle the main force were the fourth-year students of the first “production” specialisation and one third-year physics student named Ivan Todorov. For me that invitation was an event of the first magnitude and determined my mathematical interests for a long time.
Prof. Doychin Doychinov (assistant)
Prof. Tagamlitzki knew like no one else how to discover, among the students he taught, those capable of independent scientific work – in this respect he had a real talent. Moreover, he knew how to encourage a young person and to inspire confidence in his own powers. It was this, together with the fact that at his “optional” lectures (the term special course did not yet exist) and during the sessions of his circle he acquainted his listeners with some of the ideas of modern mathematics that they had nowhere else to hear at that time, that made this circle a centre of attraction for a number of young mathematicians in the 1950s. At its meetings they were introduced, while still students, into the atmosphere of intense research work. A number of our mathematicians and physicists who are well known today took their first steps in science there. With the individual members of the circle Prof. Tagamlitzki also maintained systematic personal contact, observing and guiding their work mainly by setting concrete problems. He also knew how to encourage his students, showing in this respect a remarkable psychological sense. At the same time, the young people’s contact with Prof. Tagamlitzki had an important educational effect on them of the broadest kind. He inspired in us confidence in the possibilities of Bulgarian mathematics, instilled in us respect for our mathematicians of the older generation – his teachers – and cultivated such valuable qualities as honesty and conscientiousness in research, the ability to recognise true values in science, and the striving to solve deep problems.
Prof. Todor Genchev (student)
I shall not forget the meetings of the chair, which were held every two weeks. Of course, the main topic was the discussion of the material to be covered. The main speaker was D. Doychinov, then an energetic young man and the only full-time assistant at the chair. As far as I remember, at that time Hr. Karanikolov (now deceased), Ap. Obretenov, D. Shopova and Em. Dimitrov were part-time assistants. The group of demonstrators was the most numerous, and I do not undertake to list all their names. I remember Vl. Lubich (then in his fourth year) and D. Dobrev, N. Stoev and Iv. Raychinov – third-year students. The composition of the demonstrators changed from semester to semester, but all the outstanding participants in the circle in differential and integral calculus, of which I shall speak shortly, were given this honour.
...
Much has been said and written about Tagamlitzki’s circle, though not in sufficient detail. The circle developed and grew stronger together with Tagamlitzki’s own work. Its participants changed – some came, others left... Perhaps the most intensive and fruitful period was from 1954 to 1960, when various aspects of the notion of an indecomposable vector, introduced by Tagamlitzki, were discussed. With the help of the theorem on cones proved by Tagamlitzki, new proofs of one and the same type were given for many of the central theorems of classical analysis – for example, Riesz’s theorem on the general form of linear functionals on C[a,b], Herglotz’s theorem, the moment theorems of Hausdorff and Hamburger, Bernstein’s theorem on absolutely monotone functions and its generalisation discovered by Widder, Bochner’s theorem on positive definite functions, and others. Gradually the members of the circle themselves began to obtain original scientific results. In the autumn of 1955 five members of the circle received a collective prize from the Committee for Science and Culture in the amount of 600 leva (at the rate of that time). The prizewinners were (in alphabetical order) Bl. Sendov, D. Dobrev, D. Skordev, Iv. Todorov and T. Genchev.
Prof. Dimiter Skordev (student)
My contact with Prof. Tagamlitzki became very intensive from the moment when, as a second-year student, I began to attend regularly the famous circle in differential and integral calculus. I strove to solve one or another of the problems set before the circle not only out of purely mathematical curiosity and ambition, but to a great extent also because it gave me an occasion for an interesting and substantial conversation with Prof. Tagamlitzki. Kindly praising my modest achievements, in such a conversation Prof. Tagamlitzki usually gave me many new ideas and directions for work, and I left his office even more inspired and elated. Of course, at that time I could not yet fully appreciate what great pedagogical mastery guided this man’s activity and how skilfully he helped young people to grow in science. A more accurate assessment of these things became possible much later, when life had enriched me with more experience.
Prof. Vl. Chakalov, Prof. D. Skordev (students)
To grasp better the role of the circle led by Tagamlitzki, let us take a look at the setting in which the scientific activity of this circle developed. From the Second World War until the middle of the fifties the international contacts of our mathematicians were comparatively weak. Teaching at the Faculty of Mathematics of the university was limited almost exclusively to the compulsory basic subjects, and there was nothing like the present abundance of varied special courses and seminars. Nor was there anything like the opportunities that arose later for some young people to take part, while still students, in the scientific life of some of the great universities abroad. None of the graduates then dreamed of specialising in any of the well-known scientific centres of Europe, still less overseas. The only possibility of satisfying the “scientific hunger” of the better students and young scientists was the circles of the faculty. Bearing this in mind, we can imagine what an impression was made by the sessions of a circle in which the participants were offered the chance to be full and equal collaborators in the scientific activity of their enthusiastic leader, and how easily that enthusiasm found its way to their hearts. The unique atmosphere thus created determined the further path of many of the participants in the circle. The following decade gave young mathematicians many other attractive opportunities to raise their mathematical qualifications. This took away from Tagamlitzki’s circle its aura of uniqueness and reduced the number of its members. Until the end of his life, however, Tagamlitzki regarded working with the members of the circle and introducing them to science as his foremost duty and spared no effort for it.
Lectures from the circle in functional analysis (1977–1978)
We offer for your attention manuscripts of detailed notes** of the lectures of Tagamlitzki’s course in functional analysis, delivered at the Faculty of Mathematics of Sofia University in the period 1977–1978.
* The recollections of the participants in the circle follow the volume “Yaroslav Tagamlitzki – Scholar and Teacher”. Nauka i Izkustvo, Sofia, 1986.
** The notes belong to Tagamlitzki’s then student Georgi Tenev Georgiev from Yambol, today a teacher of mathematics at the mathematical high school in Yambol.